Why you see that ‘thing’ everywhere now: The psychology of the Baader-Meinhof phenomenon

Have you ever learned a new, obscure word and then suddenly started hearing it in conversations and seeing it in articles? Or maybe you decided on a specific car model to buy, and now you see that exact car on every street corner. It feels like a strange coincidence, as if the universe is suddenly conspiring to show you this one thing. This experience, however, isn’t a glitch in the matrix or a sign from the cosmos. It’s a fascinating quirk of your own brain at work. This cognitive trick has a name: the Baader-Meinhof phenomenon, or frequency illusion. It’s a perfect example of how our minds filter reality, and understanding it reveals just how much our perception is shaped by our focus.

What exactly is the Baader-Meinhof phenomenon?

The Baader-Meinhof phenomenon describes the illusion in which something you’ve recently learned about or noticed suddenly seems to appear with improbable frequency. It’s not that the thing is actually more common; it’s that your brain is now primed to notice it. The term itself has a strange origin. In 1994, a commenter on the St. Paul Pioneer Press online forum shared an anecdote about hearing of the Baader-Meinhof Gang, a 1970s German terrorist group, twice in 24 hours. Other readers began sharing similar experiences with different topics, and they jokingly dubbed the effect the “Baader-Meinhof Phenomenon.”

Though the name is quirky, the science behind it is well-established. Psychologists more formally refer to it as the frequency illusion. At its core, it’s a cognitive bias, which is a systematic pattern of deviation from norm or rationality in judgment. Your brain isn’t playing tricks on you maliciously; it’s just trying to be efficient by creating mental shortcuts to process the immense amount of information it receives every second.

The two-part process that creates the illusion

The frequency illusion isn’t a single event but a one-two punch of cognitive processes that work together. Understanding these two parts demystifies the experience and shows how logical, and yet how fallible, our brains can be.

1. Selective attention: Your brain is a master filter. It has to be. You are constantly bombarded with sensory input like sights, sounds, and information. To prevent being completely overwhelmed, your brain prioritizes what it deems important. When you learn something new, whether it’s the name of a plant or a new tech gadget, your brain marks it as fresh, relevant, and significant. This new “tag” means your selective attention filter is now programmed to pick it out from the background noise. That yellow car was always driving past your office; you just never had a reason to notice it before.

2. Confirmation bias: This is the second step that seals the deal. Confirmation bias is the natural human tendency to search for, interpret, and recall information in a way that confirms our pre-existing beliefs or hypotheses. Once your selective attention has pointed out the “new thing,” confirmation bias kicks in. The first time you see it, it’s interesting. The second time, your brain says, “Hey, there it is again!” By the third time, your brain has established a pattern. It starts actively looking for more evidence to support the new belief: “This thing is suddenly everywhere!” Each new sighting becomes proof, reinforcing the illusion and making it feel undeniably real.

How the frequency illusion shapes your world

This cognitive bias isn’t just a fun mental quirk; it subtly influences your decisions, beliefs, and even your emotions. In marketing, advertisers try to create a Baader-Meinhof effect. Once a potential customer shows interest in a product, seeing ads for it everywhere (a process helped by digital ad retargeting) makes the product seem more popular and relevant than it might actually be. This can nudge a person toward making a purchase.

It also plays a huge role in learning. When you’re studying a new subject, you start noticing references to it in movies, news articles, and casual conversations. This can make the learning process more engaging, as it connects abstract knowledge to the real world. On the flip side, the phenomenon can fuel anxiety. For example, if you read about the symptoms of a rare illness, you might start noticing subtle feelings in your body that you previously ignored. Your confirmation bias then interprets these as proof that you have the illness, leading to unnecessary worry.

Putting the Baader-Meinhof effect to work for you

While you can’t turn off this cognitive bias, you can become aware of it and even leverage it for your benefit. Awareness is the first step. By simply knowing that the frequency illusion exists, you can pause and ask yourself, “Is this new trend really a trend, or am I just noticing it more?” This simple question can help you make more rational decisions and reduce anxiety driven by perceived patterns.

More proactively, you can use it to shape your reality. If you want to cultivate a more positive outlook, you can consciously decide to look for acts of kindness, moments of beauty, or things to be grateful for. At first, it might feel forced. But soon, your brain’s selective attention will start picking up on these positive things automatically. Your confirmation bias will then reinforce this pattern, and you may genuinely start to feel that the world around you is a kinder, more positive place. You can essentially trick your brain into focusing on the good.

Conclusion

The feeling that a newfound word, car, or idea is suddenly everywhere is not a coincidence but a powerful demonstration of how your brain works. The Baader-Meinhof phenomenon, or frequency illusion, is a natural process rooted in two fundamental cognitive biases: selective attention and confirmation bias. Your brain first flags new information as important, making you notice it, and then seeks out further evidence to confirm its newfound prevalence. This mental shortcut helps us learn and find patterns, but it can also skew our perception of reality, influencing everything from our purchases to our anxieties. By understanding this trick of the mind, we can not only see the world more clearly but also learn to harness it, directing our focus toward what we want to see more of in our lives.

Image by: RDNE Stock project
https://www.pexels.com/@rdne