Why they do it: The baffling unsolved mysteries of animal behavior

The natural world often operates with a beautiful, predictable rhythm. A lion stalks its prey, a spider spins its web, a beaver builds its dam. These are the instincts we understand, the behaviors ingrained by millennia of evolution for one simple purpose: survival. But what happens when animals act in ways that defy this logic? What about the actions that offer no clear benefit, that seem to serve a purpose far beyond our comprehension? The animal kingdom is filled with these profound puzzles. From astonishing feats of navigation that rival our best technology to eerie premonitions of disaster, some animal behaviors remain baffling, unsolved mysteries that challenge the very core of what we think we know about life on Earth.

The great navigation puzzle

Perhaps one of the most awe-inspiring mysteries is the phenomenon of long-distance migration. Every year, millions of animals embark on epic journeys spanning thousands of miles, yet how they navigate with such pinpoint accuracy remains a profound question. The Arctic Tern, for example, travels from the Arctic to the Antarctic and back again, a round trip of about 44,000 miles. How does it find its way across vast, featureless oceans?

Scientists have several theories, but no single one provides a complete answer. It’s believed that many animals possess a kind of biological toolkit for navigation:

• Magnetoreception: This is the ability to sense the Earth’s magnetic field. Some researchers believe birds have proteins in their eyes that allow them to literally see magnetic lines, creating a visual “heads-up display” to guide their flight.
• Sun and star compasses: Many animals, from birds to insects like the Monarch butterfly, use the position of the sun and stars to orient themselves. They even have an internal clock to compensate for the movement of these celestial bodies throughout the day and night.
• Olfactory maps: Some species, like salmon and sea turtles, are thought to use their sense of smell to navigate. They imprint on the unique chemical signature of their birthplace and follow these subtle scent trails back home years later.

While we can identify these tools, the true mystery is how they are integrated. How does a sea turtle combine magnetic sense, celestial cues, and smell to cross an entire ocean and find the exact beach where it was born? The complexity of this integrated system is a puzzle we are only just beginning to piece together.

Whispers before the storm

Folklore is rich with tales of animals behaving strangely just before a natural disaster strikes. Dogs howl incessantly, snakes emerge from hibernation, and birds fall silent. For centuries, this was dismissed as superstition. However, a growing body of anecdotal and scientific evidence suggests there may be truth to this “sixth sense.” During the 2004 Indian Ocean tsunami, there were widespread reports of elephants screaming and running for high ground minutes before the waves hit, while other animals like flamingos abandoned their low-lying breeding areas.

Scientists are investigating plausible explanations for this incredible animal instinct. Animals are far more sensitive to subtle environmental changes than humans are. They might not be “predicting the future,” but rather detecting physical precursors to the event:

• Sensing seismic waves: Earthquakes produce different types of seismic waves. The initial, faster-moving P-waves are often too faint for humans to feel, but animals might detect these vibrations, giving them a crucial head start before the more destructive S-waves arrive.
• Changes in air pressure: Storms and other weather events are preceded by shifts in atmospheric pressure that sensitive animals could perceive.
• Infrasound: Events like avalanches, volcanoes, and tsunamis can generate low-frequency sounds (infrasound) that travel long distances. Humans can’t hear them, but animals like elephants can, potentially providing them with an early warning.

The challenge for science is to move from anecdote to hard data. Studying animal behavior in the chaotic moments before a disaster is incredibly difficult, leaving this one of the most tantalizing and elusive mysteries of animal behavior.

The tragedy of mass strandings

Few sights in nature are as heartbreaking and confusing as a mass stranding of whales or dolphins. These highly intelligent, social marine mammals suddenly and inexplicably beach themselves, often leading to their deaths. Why would creatures perfectly adapted to the ocean voluntarily strand themselves on land? This question has baffled marine biologists for decades, and the answer is likely not a single one, but a complex combination of factors.

One leading theory points to navigational errors. Many mass strandings occur on gently sloping, sandy coastlines. It’s thought that the sonar (echolocation) that whales and dolphins use to navigate is less effective in these environments, possibly confusing them into thinking they are in open water. Another possibility is a disruption of the Earth’s magnetic field, which they may also use for navigation, leading them astray.

Human activity is also a major suspect. The powerful sonar used by military submarines and some survey ships can be disorienting and even physically harmful to cetaceans, potentially causing them to panic and flee into shallow waters. Finally, their deep social bonds could play a tragic role. If a dominant or sick individual in a pod makes a navigational mistake, the strong social cohesion of the group may compel the others to follow, even to their doom.

The question of a deeper consciousness

Beyond instinct and survival, we see animal behaviors that hint at something more: a complex inner world of emotion, thought, and even self-awareness. While we can’t ask an animal what it’s thinking, its actions can be profoundly suggestive. Elephants have been observed visiting the bones of their deceased relatives, gently touching them with their trunks in what appears to be a form of grief or mourning. New Caledonian crows solve complex, multi-step puzzles to get food, demonstrating a capacity for planning and abstract thought that rivals that of a young child.

Even more compelling is the evidence for empathy. Studies have shown that rats will work to free a trapped cage-mate, even when offered a chocolate treat as an alternative. This suggests they are motivated not by a simple reward, but by a desire to alleviate the distress of another. The ultimate mystery here is not what they are doing, but why. Are these behaviors just highly sophisticated, pre-programmed responses, or do they signify a genuine spark of consciousness, emotion, and empathy? The line between complex instinct and true sentience is blurry, and it represents one of the final frontiers in our understanding of the animal mind.

From the precise, invisible maps used by migrating birds to the tragic, loyal followings of stranded whales, the animal kingdom is a realm of enduring mystery. We have explored the leading theories behind these baffling behaviors—magnetoreception, seismic sensitivity, sonar disruption, and the tantalizing hints of a deeper consciousness. Yet, for every answer science proposes, more questions arise. These unsolved puzzles serve as a powerful and humbling reminder that despite all our advancements, we are still just beginning to understand the complex, intelligent, and often inexplicable lives of the creatures with whom we share this planet. The world is not just what we can see and explain; it is also filled with a deep, instinctual wisdom that continues to elude us.

Image by: Burak The Weekender
https://www.pexels.com/@weekendplayer